Back

Side-by-Side vs. ATV: Which Is Right for You?

Sep. 12 2025 Buying Guide By Warhorse Williamsport

Share

Side-by-Side vs. ATV: Which Is Right for You?

If you’re shopping for an off-road vehicle in Pennsylvania, chances are you’ve asked yourself the big question:

👉 “Should I buy an ATV or a side-by-side (UTV)?”

Both are designed for fun and utility, but they serve different types of riders. Let’s break down the differences so you can decide which machine is the better fit for your adventures in the Poconos and beyond.

What Is an ATV?

An All-Terrain Vehicle (ATV) is typically a four-wheeler designed for single-rider use, with some models accommodating a passenger. ATVs are lightweight, nimble, and great for tight trails.

Pros of an ATV:

  • Smaller and easier to transport on a trailer or in a truck bed

  • Better maneuverability on narrow or technical trails

  • Lower upfront cost compared to UTVs

  • Easier for solo riders who want quick handling

Cons of an ATV:

  • Limited storage and passenger space

  • Less protection from weather or debris

  • More physically demanding to ride for long periods

What Is a Side-by-Side (UTV)?

A Utility Task Vehicle (UTV), often called a side-by-side, has bucket seats, a steering wheel, and usually seats for 2–6 people. They’re larger, more powerful, and built for comfort and utility.

Pros of a UTV:

  • Seats multiple riders → perfect for families or groups

  • Plenty of cargo space for gear, coolers, or hunting equipment

  • Safer: roll cages, seatbelts, windshields, and roofs available

  • Stronger engines and suspension for heavy hauling or rough terrain

Cons of a UTV:

  • Larger size can limit access to narrow trails

  • More expensive than ATVs

  • Requires a trailer for transport (won’t fit in most truck beds)

Which One Is Right for Pennsylvania Riders?

It depends on how and where you ride:

  • Trail Riders in the Poconos → ATVs are a better fit for tight, wooded trails like those at Lost Trails in Dunmore.

  • Families & Groups → Side-by-sides make more sense, since everyone can ride together.

  • Hunters & Landowners → A UTV with storage racks and cargo space is ideal for hauling supplies.

  • Budget-Conscious Riders → ATVs are more affordable upfront and easier to maintain.

  • Year-Round Adventurers → Side-by-sides offer better comfort and adaptability (add a cab or heater for winter riding).

Popular ATVs and Side-by-Sides in 2025

Top ATV Picks:

  • Polaris Sportsman 570 → versatile, comfortable, great for beginners and veterans alike.

  • Honda FourTrax Rancher → reliable, low-maintenance, built for both work and play.

  • Yamaha Grizzly 700 → powerful option for serious trail riders.

Top UTV Picks:

  • Polaris Ranger 1000 → a workhorse side-by-side, perfect for farming or land management.

  • Can-Am Maverick Sport → sporty, agile, great for thrill-seekers.

  • Yamaha Wolverine RMAX2 1000 → balance of utility and comfort with premium features.

Final Thoughts

There’s no wrong choice — both ATVs and side-by-sides deliver fun, utility, and adventure. The real decision comes down to how you’ll use your machine.

👉 If you’re riding solo on tight trails, an ATV might be the perfect fit.
👉 If you want to ride with family, haul gear, or enjoy more comfort, a side-by-side is hard to beat.

At Warhorse, we carry every major ATV and UTV brand — Polaris, Honda, Can-Am, Yamaha, Kawasaki, and more. Our team can help you compare models side-by-side (literally!) and find the right machine for your lifestyle.

Stop by our showroom in Northeast PA and let’s match you with the perfect ride.